Q&A

(2008) Question 75: The butane stream from a catalytic polymerization (cat poly) unit, which contains 69% isobutene, 14% butylenes, and 17% normal butane, would appear to be an excellent alkylation unit feedstock, especially if isobutene is i

METKA (Sunoco, Inc.) We operate a cat poly and sulfuric alkylation unit within the same refinery. The configuration offers flexibility and synergies that allow various operating and business demands to be met. In our configuration, the cat poly debutanizer overhead feeds the alkylation unit to

(2008) Question 76 The regeneration of feed dryers/sulfur guard beds on butane isomerization units generates a butane slop stream. Will processing this butane slop stream in an HF or sulfuric acid alkylation unit cause any problems? If so, what else may be done with this slop stream?

QUINTANA (Valero Energy Corporation) The spent Isom regenerant will contain butanes that are attractive to recover. They can come from generally any of three sources: either the treated normal butane feed downstream of the on-stream dryer, the fractionated isobutene from the Deisobutanizer fractionator overhead, or the isomerate product is used as the regenerant source. The spent regenerant also contains all of the sulfur and oxygenate impurities that were previously accumulated on the sieve; and after the spent regenerant coalescer, it will also be saturated with water.

(2008) Question 77 What is your experience with cooling water exchangers in an HF alkylation unit? How long do you go between cleanings? Do you have a special water treatment program for cooling towers dedicated to the alkylation unit?

KAISER (Delek Refining Ltd.) In my experience, the cooling water exchangers in an HF alkylation unit are really no more problematic than any other exchanger in the refinery when you’re looking at the waterside only. If you have an exchanger in the HF alkylation unit that suffers from low flow or it’s at the end of a header, trapped scale, and there are certainly critical exchangers inside the alkylation unit that you want to keep clean, it’s really no different if it’s in the alkylation unit or in some other unit in the refinery. You’re going to have water problems and that’s going to generate issues for you.

(2008) Question 78 For HF alkylation units, have you changed your criteria for materials given the low availability of low carbon/non-recycled steel? Are you heat treating welds? Can you control Brinell Hardness with welding procedures? For small bore pipe, do you recommend using flanges or threaded pipe?

KAISER (Delek Refining Ltd.) Again, just to re-emphasize, I’m not currently on an HF unit so part of this response will rely on some former colleagues of mine. I would not make a blanket recommendation to change the material specification for carbon steel in HF alkylation units. To me, the risk is too great. I understand that there are certain times when things are tight and you might need immediate material delivery and there’s no other option, but I would not make a blanket relaxation in the material specifications.

(2008) Question 86: The reformer’s feed properties can be affected when the refinery is maximizing refinery diesel yield. How do these changes to reformer feed affect performance with respect to C5+ yield, hydrogen production, cycle length, and economics?

NEWTON (Roddey Engineering Services, Inc.) As everyone knows, we’re not here to discuss how to make more gasoline; we’re here at the conference to learn how to make more diesel, so I just hope you people in here... But whenever you start to talk about maximizing diesel yield from most refineries, what you’re going to talk about is shifting the heavy end of the reformer feed to the diesel stream and so you lower your endpoint to the reformer.

(2008) Question 87: Iron contamination of CCR, cyclic, and semi-regen reformer catalyst is a common problem. What level of iron concentration typically justifies catalyst replacement due to poor catalyst performance?

METKA (Sunoco, Inc.) Typically, iron levels up to approximately 12,000 ppm can be tolerated before a change-out is required. Iron is a support modifier that can affect both the metal and acid sites. There is more of an impact on the acid sites, and iron can impede chloride pick-up and trap sulfur on the catalyst. Iron typically impacts the first reactor in a fixed-bed unit and is primarily a result of upstream corrosion in the naphtha hydrotreater.

(2008) Question 88: What is your experience with feed-side fouling on combined feed/effluent (CFE) exchangers? What is the foulant? How often do you clean them and what cleaning techniques do you use? On Texas Towers (vertical shell & tube exchangers), how do you extract the bundle from the shell if it gets stuck?

NEWTON (Roddey Engineering Services, Inc. Engineering) I’m just going to deal with Roddey Engineering’s experience. I know some people on the panel have different experiences. But as far as feed effluent exchangers go, and especially Texas Towers, we have seen significant fouling on all that we’ve dealt with. Pretty much every refinery that has one, they do not clean the tower.

(2019) Question 2: We have a Selective Hydrogeneration Units (SHU) unit that removes butadiene from the olefin feed to the alkylation unit. What is the typical concentration of hydrogen and light ends in the olefin product leaving the SHU? How do hydrogen and light ends affect alky operations?

THOMAS PORRITT (Chevron U.S.A)
A selective hydrogenation unit or SHU converts diolefins to olefins in a stream before it feeds an alkylation unit.

Below is a basic flow scheme.

Figure Q2 - 1 Selective Hydrogenation Unit Flow Scheme

The typical composition of non-condensable gases and light

(2019) Question 3: What is your experience with ball valves in feed and make-up gas drier circuits in ISOM Units? What strategies have you adopted for monitoring leaks, regular maintenance and achieving longer run length?

DAVINDER MITTAL (HPCL Mittal Energy)

The gas and liquid dryers perform important task of safeguarding the ISOM catalyst from water vapor and other impurities in the make-up hydrogen and hydrocarbon feed.
The dryer switching valves play an important role of directing the inlet/outlet gas streams

(2019) Question 4: What are your best practices for controlling caustic strength in an isomerization unit scrubber? How frequently is the caustic refreshed?

It is quite important to optimize PERC injection in feed as guided by technology supplier as otherwise the HCl concentration in off gas can go too high (normal range 1500 - 2500 ppm). This will lead to rapid depletion of caustic strength due to neutralization effect, thereby requiring frequent fresh caustic make-up.

Find the answer to your technical question in AFPM's extensive Q&A database.

Q&A